Article 88a
Amendments as tabled
31 amendments, each tabled separately · IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
405 ~Alternative Piotr MüllerECR · IMCO “and is based on one of the legal bases set out in Article 6 of this Regulation”
(1) Storing of personal data, or gaining of access to personal data already stored, in the terminal equipment of a natural person shall be lawful where processing of such data is
onlycarriedallowed when that person has given his or her consent,out in accordance with this Regulation and is based on one of the legal bases set out in Article 6 of this Regulation.- Tabled by
- Piotr Müller
- Group
- ECR
- Targets
- GDPR Article 88a(1)
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Source
- Official text, page 49
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / Article 88a – paragraph 1
406 +Addition David CormandGreens/EFA · IMCO “A consumer shall not be denied access to a service or to a functionality of a service on the grounds that the person has not given consent under…” numbered 1a
(1a)A consumer shall not be denied access to a service or to a functionality of a service on the grounds that the person has not given consent under paragraph 1 to the storing of, or gaining of access to personal data in terminal equipment that is not strictly necessary for the provision of that service or functionality.
- Tabled by
- David Cormand on behalf of the Verts/ALE Group
- Group
- Greens/EFA
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Source
- Official text, page 49
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / 88 a new
407 ~Alternative Piotr MüllerECR · IMCO “point (f), of this Regulation (EU), the GDPR requires a balancing test to ensure that the company’s interests do not override the user’s rights and…”
(2)
Paragraph 1 does not preclude storing of personal data, or gaining of access to personal data already stored, in the terminal equipment of a natural person, based on Union or Member State law within the meaning of, and subject to the conditions of Article 6, to safeguard the objectives referred to in Article 23(1).Where the processing referred to in paragraph 1 is based on legitimate interests pursuant to Article 6(1), point (f), of this Regulation (EU), the GDPR requires a balancing test to ensure that the company’s interests do not override the user’s rights and reasonable expectations, this principle should we always respect and strive to achieve the right balance.- Tabled by
- Piotr Müller
- Group
- ECR
- Targets
- GDPR Article 88a(2)
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Source
- Official text, page 50
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / Article 88a – paragraph 2
408 ~Alternative Piotr MüllerECR · IMCO “rely on other applicable legal bases under Regulation (EU) 2016/679”
(3)
Storing of personal data, or gaining of access to personal data already stored, in the terminal equipment of a natural person without consent, and subsequent processing, shall be lawful to the extent it is necessary for any of the following:The following operational data processing activities shall not require consent under paragraph 1, and may rely on other applicable legal bases under Regulation (EU) 2016/679, subject to the conditions and safeguards set out in that Regulation:- Tabled by
- Piotr Müller
- Group
- ECR
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Source
- Official text, page 50
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / Article 88a – paragraph 3
409 ~Alternative David CormandGreens/EFA · IMCO “such access shall be strictly limited to what is technically necessary for the sole purpose of transmitting the communication to ensure the highest…”
(a) carrying out the transmission of an electronic communication over an electronic communications network; such access shall be strictly limited to what is technically necessary for the sole purpose of transmitting the communication to ensure the highest level of consumer protection. Such access shall not be used for purposes unrelated to the transmission of the communication, including profiling, advertising, audience measurement, service optimisation, or the creation of behavioural or usage analytics.
- Tabled by
- David Cormand on behalf of the Verts/ALE Group
- Group
- Greens/EFA
- Targets
- GDPR Article 88a(3)(a)
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / Article 88 a new
410 −Deletion Virginie JoronPfE · IMCO Deletes the Commission’s wording
(c) creating aggregated information about the usage of an online service to measure the audience of such a service, where it is carried out by the controller of that online service solely for its own use;- Tabled by
- Virginie Joron
- Group
- PfE
- Targets
- GDPR Article 88a(3)(c)
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Source
- Official text, page 51
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / Article 88 a – paragraph 3 – point c
411 ~Alternative David CormandGreens/EFA · IMCO “is restricted to aggregated statistical counting does not enable the identification, tracking or profiling of consumers beyond what is strictly…”
(c) instantly creating aggregated and anonymous measurement information about the usage of an online service to measure the audience of such a service, where such measurement it is carried out by the controller of that online service solely for its own use,; is restricted to aggregated statistical counting does not enable the identification, tracking or profiling of consumers beyond what is strictly necessary for aggregated statistics and does not involve the creation of persistent identifiers, provided that the data is not combined with data from other services from the same provider or from a third party or made accessible to third parties, subject to provisions laid down in Regulation (EU) 2022/1925 or otherwise processed for purposes such as profiling, advertising, the optimisation of services beyond audience measurement, or the training of artificial intelligence systems, and provided that data subjects are given effective means to object without affecting the usability of the service.
- Tabled by
- David Cormand on behalf of the Verts/ALE Group
- Group
- Greens/EFA
- Targets
- GDPR Article 88a(3)(c)
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / Article 88 a new
412 ~Alternative Christian DoleschalEPP · IMCO “or by entitled third parties jointly authorised by advertisers and publishers, solely for the measurement of the overall market performance and…”
(c)
creatingmeasuring the audience of an online service in order to draw aggregated information about the usage of an online service to measure the audience of such a service, as defined by article 2 (16) of Regulation 2024/1083, where it is carried out by the controller of that online service solely for its own use or by entitled third parties jointly authorised by advertisers and publishers, solely for the measurement of the overall market performance and subject to the safeguards laid down in Article 89(1);- Tabled by
- Christian Doleschal
- Group
- EPP
- Targets
- GDPR Article 88a(3)(c)
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / Article 88a paragraph 3c
413 ~Alternative Sabine VerheyenEPP · IMCO “measuring the audience of an online service as defined in Article 2(16) of Regulation 2024/1083 to create”
(c)
creatingmeasuring the audience of an online service as defined in Article 2(16) of Regulation 2024/1083 to create aggregated information about the usage of an online service to measure the audience of such a service, where it is carried out bythe controller ofthat online service or by entitled third parties jointly authorised by adverstisers or publishers, solely foritstheownmeasurementuseof the overall market performance and subject to the safeguards laid down in Article 89(1);- Tabled by
- Sabine Verheyen
- Group
- EPP
- Targets
- GDPR Article 88a(3)(c)
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Source
- Official text, page 53
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / GDPR / Art. 26
414 ~Alternative Piotr MüllerECR · IMCO “the prevention of fraud or other risky behaviour or technical incidents”
(c)
creating aggregated information about the usage of an online service to measure the audience of such a service, where it is carried out by the controller of that online service solely for its own use;measuring or improving the performance, security or functionality of an online service, including through testing and the creation of aggregated usage information, where such processing is carried out solely for the controller’s own use, the prevention of fraud or other risky behaviour or technical incidents- Tabled by
- Piotr Müller
- Group
- ECR
- Targets
- GDPR Article 88a(3)(c)
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / Article 88a – paragraph 3 (c)
415 ~Alternative David CormandGreens/EFA · IMCO “provided that it is limited to what is strictly necessary for ensuring a specific security purpose or addressing concrete security vulnerabilities or…”
(d)
maintaining or restoring the security of a service provided by the controller and requested by the data subject or the terminal equipment used for the provision of such service.maintenance or restoration of the security of a service provided by the controller and requested explicitly by the data subject provided that it is limited to what is strictly necessary for ensuring a specific security purpose or addressing concrete security vulnerabilities or incidents affecting the requested service or device. Measures under this point shall not alter the functionality of the hardware or software, or the privacy settings chosen by the consumer, unrelated to that purpose. Access shall not be used to generate persistent identifiers, behavioural profiles, or long-term activity logs, nor shall it introduce device fingerprinting, device graphing, or similar techniques enabling tracking across services or applications.- Tabled by
- David Cormand on behalf of the Verts/ALE Group
- Group
- Greens/EFA
- Targets
- GDPR Article 88a(3)(d)
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / Article 88 a new
416 ~Alternative Virginie JoronPfE · IMCO “maintaining or restoring the integrity or security of a service provided by the controller and requested by the data subject or the terminal…”
(d) maintaining or restoring the integrity or security of a service provided by the controller and requested by the data subject or the terminal equipment used for the provision of such service.
- Tabled by
- Virginie Joron
- Group
- PfE
- Targets
- GDPR Article 88a(3)(d)
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Source
- Official text, page 55
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / Article 88 a – paragraph 3 – point d
417 ~Alternative Piotr MüllerECR · IMCO “maintaining, restoring or ensuring the security of a service or of the terminal equipment used for the provision of such service.”
(d) maintaining, restoring or
restoringensuring the security of a serviceprovidedorby the controller and requested by the data subject orof the terminal equipment used for the provision of such service.- Tabled by
- Piotr Müller
- Group
- ECR
- Targets
- GDPR Article 88a(3)(d)
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Source
- Official text, page 55
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / Article 88a – paragraph 3 (d)
418 +Addition David CormandGreens/EFA · IMCO “measuring the display and performance of contextual advertising provided that the processing of personal data is strictly limited to the activities…”
(da)measuring the display and performance of contextual advertising provided that the processing of personal data is strictly limited to the activities falling under the definition in Article 4 (b) (xx), provided that consumers data including possibly identifying data and metadata is deleted immediately after the browsing session is closed and provided any data collection and processing for this purpose is kept within what is strictly necessary and in respect of the data minimisation principle and purpose limitation as set out in Articles 5(1)(b) and 5 (1)(c);
This provision can be invoked only where the controller is able to demonstrate, upon request by a Data Protection Authority, that it uses exclusively temporary, transient, non-persistent tracking technologies immediately deleted after the browsing session and technically designed to expire automatically at the moment the advertisement has been displayed and any strictly necessary measurement of its display or performance has occurred..
- Tabled by
- David Cormand on behalf of the Verts/ALE Group
- Group
- Greens/EFA
- Targets
- GDPR Article 88a
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / Article 88 a new
419 +Addition Piotr MüllerECR · IMCO “analytics and audience measurement for the purpose of understanding aggregate service usage or advertising campaign performance, provided the results…”
(da)analytics and audience measurement for the purpose of understanding aggregate service usage or advertising campaign performance, provided the results are not used to profi le individual users;
- Tabled by
- Piotr Müller
- Group
- ECR
- Targets
- GDPR Article 88a(3)
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / Article 88a – paragraph 3
420 +Addition Piotr MüllerECR · IMCO “direct marketing communications addressed to existing customers in respect of the controller’s own products and services, in accordance with…”
(db)direct marketing communications addressed to existing customers in respect of the controller’s own products and services, in accordance with applicable rules;
- Tabled by
- Piotr Müller
- Group
- ECR
- Targets
- GDPR Article 88a(3)
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Source
- Official text, page 57
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / Article 88a – paragraph 3
421 +Addition Piotr MüllerECR · IMCO “processing strictly necessary for the detection and prevention of cyberattacks, fraud, and unauthorised access, and for the maintenance of technical…”
(dc)processing strictly necessary for the detection and prevention of cyberattacks, fraud, and unauthorised access, and for the maintenance of technical service performance;
- Tabled by
- Piotr Müller
- Group
- ECR
- Targets
- GDPR Article 88a(3)
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / Article 88a – paragraph 3
422 +Addition Piotr MüllerECR · IMCO “frequency capping of advertising within a single service environment, where no cross-service tracking or persistent profiling is involved;”
(dd)frequency capping of advertising within a single service environment, where no cross-service tracking or persistent profiling is involved;
- Tabled by
- Piotr Müller
- Group
- ECR
- Targets
- GDPR Article 88a(3)
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Source
- Official text, page 58
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / Article 88a – paragraph 3
423 +Addition Piotr MüllerECR · IMCO “processing where the controller deploys recognised privacy-enhancing technologies (PETs) that effectively mitigate risks to the rights and freedoms…”
(de)processing where the controller deploys recognised privacy-enhancing technologies (PETs) that effectively mitigate risks to the rights and freedoms of data subjects, in accordance with the technical specifications adopted pursuant to paragraph 4, 5 and 6.
- Tabled by
- Piotr Müller
- Group
- ECR
- Targets
- GDPR Article 88a(3)
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Source
- Official text, page 58
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / Article 88a – paragraph 3
424 +Addition David CormandGreens/EFA · IMCO “Personal data of consumers accessed pursuant to paragraph 3 shall be processed only insofar as strictly necessary for the purpose of justifying the…” numbered 3a
(3a)Personal data of consumers accessed pursuant to paragraph 3 shall be processed only insofar as strictly necessary for the purpose of justifying the access and shall not be further processed for incompatible purposes to ensure the highest level of consumer protection. Article 6(4) shall not apply to such processing. Personal data of consumers accessed pursuant to paragraph 3 shall be deleted or rendered anonymous immediately after the purpose justifying the access has been fulfilled.
- Tabled by
- David Cormand on behalf of the Verts/ALE Group
- Group
- Greens/EFA
- Targets
- GDPR Article 88a(3)(a)
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / Article 88 a new – paragraph 3 a (new)
425 −Deletion Piotr MüllerECR · IMCO Deletes the Commission’s wording
(4) Where storing of personal data, or gaining of access to personal data already stored, in the terminal equipment of a natural person is based on consent, the following shall apply: (a) the data subject shall be able to refuse requests for consent in an easy and intelligible manner with a single-click button or equivalent means; (b) if the data subject gives consent, the controller shall not make a new request for consent for the same purpose for the period during which the controller can lawfully rely on the consent of the data subject; (c) if the data subject declines a request for consent, the controller shall not make a new request for consent for the same purpose for a period of at least six months. This paragraph also applies to the subsequent processing of personal data based on consent.- Tabled by
- Piotr Müller
- Group
- ECR
- Targets
- GDPR Article 88a(4)
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / Article 88a – paragraph 4
426 −Deletion Sabine VerheyenEPP · IMCO Deletes the Commission’s wording
(4) Where storing of personal data, or gaining of access to personal data already stored, in the terminal equipment of a natural person is based on consent, the following shall apply: (a) the data subject shall be able to refuse requests for consent in an easy and intelligible manner with a single-click button or equivalent means; (b) if the data subject gives consent, the controller shall not make a new request for consent for the same purpose for the period during which the controller can lawfully rely on the consent of the data subject; (c) if the data subject declines a request for consent, the controller shall not make a new request for consent for the same purpose for a period of at least six months. This paragraph also applies to the subsequent processing of personal data based on consent.- Tabled by
- Sabine Verheyen
- Group
- EPP
- Targets
- GDPR Article 88a(4)
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / GDPR / Article 88a (4)
427 ~Alternative Virginie JoronPfE · IMCO “only be valid if it is freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous, and takes the form of a statement or a clear affirmative action, in…”
Where storing of personal data, or gaining of access to personal data already stored, in the terminal equipment of a natural person is based on consent, the following shall apply:Where storing of personal data, or gaining of access to personal data already stored, in the terminal equipment of a natural person is based on consent, the consent shall only be valid if it is freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous, and takes the form of a statement or a clear affirmative action, in accordance with Article 4, point (11), and Article 7 of this Regulation, in accordance with Guidelines 05/2020 of the European Data Protection Board on consent. It must be as easy for the data subject to refuse or withdraw consent as it was to give consent, and any such refusal or withdrawal must be without detriment. The interface used to request, give, refuse or withdraw consent shall be designed, organised and used in accordance with Article 25 of Regulation (EU) 2022/2065 and must not deceive or manipulate the data subject or materially distort or impair his or her ability to make free and informed decisions.- Tabled by
- Virginie Joron
- Group
- PfE
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Source
- Official text, page 61
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / Article 88 a
428 ~Alternative David CormandGreens/EFA · IMCO “it shall be as easy to refuse or withdraw consent as to give it”
(a) the
data subjectconsumer shall be able to exercise their choice to refuse requests for consent or withdraw consent inanaeasyconsumer-friendly, accessible,n andintelligibleeasy manner with a single-click button or equivalent means; it shall be as easy to refuse or withdraw consent as to give it;- Tabled by
- David Cormand on behalf of the Verts/ALE Group
- Group
- Greens/EFA
- Targets
- GDPR Article 88a(4)(a)
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / Article 88 a new
429 +Addition David CormandGreens/EFA · IMCO “consent that uses unfair commercial practices that influence or manipulate the free and genuine consumer choice to consent shall make consent void;”
(aa)consent that uses unfair commercial practices that influence or manipulate the free and genuine consumer choice to consent shall make consent void;
- Tabled by
- David Cormand on behalf of the Verts/ALE Group
- Group
- Greens/EFA
- Targets
- GDPR Article 88a
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Source
- Official text, page 62
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / Article 88 a new
430 ~Alternative David CormandGreens/EFA · IMCO “When a user has refused or withdrawn consent, electronic communications service providers and third parties may not seek the user’s consent again…”
(b) if the data subject gives consent, the controller shall not make a new request for consent for the same purpose for the period during which the controller can lawfully rely on the consent of the data subject; When a user has refused or withdrawn consent, electronic communications service providers and third parties may not seek the user’s consent again until one year has elapsed from the date of the user’s decision for the same processing purpose.
- Tabled by
- David Cormand on behalf of the Verts/ALE Group
- Group
- Greens/EFA
- Targets
- GDPR Article 88a(4)(b)
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / Article 88 a new
431 ~Alternative David CormandGreens/EFA · IMCO “Cross-service tracking techniques or data reuse for incompatible purposes shall also be excluded in line with provision under Regulation (EU)…”
(c) if the data subject declines a request for consent, the controller shall not make a new request for consent for the same purpose for a period of at least six months. Cross-service tracking techniques or data reuse for incompatible purposes shall also be excluded in line with provision under Regulation (EU) 2022/1925.
- Tabled by
- David Cormand on behalf of the Verts/ALE Group
- Group
- Greens/EFA
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Source
- Official text, page 63
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / Article 88 a new
432 ~Alternative David CormandGreens/EFA · IMCO “New requests for consent within these periods, precludes consent from being validly granted.”
New requests for consent within these periods, precludes consent from being validly granted. This paragraph also applies to the subsequent processing of personal data based on consent.
- Tabled by
- David Cormand on behalf of the Verts/ALE Group
- Group
- Greens/EFA
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / Article 88a new
433 +Addition Piotr MüllerECR · IMCO “The Commission may adopt implementing acts to specify the technical standards and criteria to determine whether a technology qualifies as a…” numbered 4a
(4a)The Commission may adopt implementing acts to specify the technical standards and criteria to determine whether a technology qualifies as a recognised Privacy Enhancing Technology (PET) and effectively mitigates risks as referred to in paragraph 3.
- Tabled by
- Piotr Müller
- Group
- ECR
- Targets
- GDPR Article 88a(4)
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Source
- Official text, page 64
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / Article 88a – paragraph 4
434 +Addition Piotr MüllerECR · IMCO “For the purpose of paragraph 4 the Commission shall: (a) assess the state of the art of available technologies; (b)develop criteria to assess the…” numbered 4b
(4b)For the purpose of paragraph 4 the Commission shall: (a) assess the state of the art of available technologies; (b)develop criteria to assess the effectiveness of risk mitigation in relation to the specific categories of data and processing operations.
- Tabled by
- Piotr Müller
- Group
- ECR
- Targets
- GDPR Article 88a
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / Article 88a
435 +Addition Piotr MüllerECR · IMCO “The Commission shall closely involve the EDPB in the preparations of the implementing acts. The EDPB shall issue an opinion on the draft implementing…” numbered 4c
(4c)The Commission shall closely involve the EDPB in the preparations of the implementing acts. The EDPB shall issue an opinion on the draft implementing acts within a deadline of 8 weeks as of the receipt of the draft from the Commission. The Implementing Acts shall be adopted in accordance with the examination procedure referred to in Article 93(3).
- Tabled by
- Piotr Müller
- Group
- ECR
- Targets
- GDPR Article 88a
- Document
- IMCO amendments 329–532 to the draft opinion
- Source
- Official text, page 65
- Printed header
- Article 3 – paragraph 1 – point 15 / Regulation (EU) 2016/679 / Article 88a