Article 35
Amendments as tabled
Three amendments, each tabled separately · IMCO amendments 125–328 to the draft opinion
273 ~Alternative Piotr Müller +1ECR · IMCO “Before adopting common specifications, the Commission shall demonstrate, on the basis of a public technical and economic assessment, that they are…”
16a. In Article 35, paragraph 5 is amended as follows:
5. The Commission may, by means of implementing acts, adopt common specifications based on open interoperability specifications covering all of the essential requirements laid down in paragraphs 1 and 2 only where no harmonised standard or standards covering the relevant requirements are available, no standardisation work covering those requirements is ongoing, and the relevant European standardisation organisations have formally refused the request to develop harmonised standards. Before adopting common specifications, the Commission shall demonstrate, on the basis of a public technical and economic assessment, that they are strictly necessary, technically and economically feasible, and proportionate. Any common specifications adopted pursuant to this paragraph shall not go beyond the essential requirements laid down in paragraphs 1 and 2 and shall not impose additional technical design, architectural, operational or commercial obligations."
Justification
This amendment prevents the Data Act from becoming an outlier in EU law by allowing Commission-mandated common specifications without a prior standardisation process. In line with better law-making, proportionality and market-driven standardisation, common specifications must remain a last-resort tool, based on evidence and feasibility, not a shortcut for politically imposed technical solutions or new obligations beyond the Regulation’s essential requirements.
- Tabled by
- Piotr Müller, Diego Solier
- Group
- ECR
- Document
- IMCO amendments 125–328 to the draft opinion
- Printed header
- Article 1 – paragraph 1 – point 16 a (new) / Regulation 2023/2854 / Article 35 – paragraph 5
274 ~Alternative Piotr Müller +1ECR · IMCO “References to common specifications shall not be published unless those common specifications have been adopted in accordance with paragraph 5 and 6.…”
16b. In Article 35, paragraph 8 is amended as follows:
8. For the purpose of Article 30(3), the Commission
shallmay, by means of implementing acts, publish the references of harmonised standards and common specifications for the interoperability of data processing services in a central Union standards repository for the interoperability of data processing services. References to common specifications shall not be published unless those common specifications have been adopted in accordance with paragraph 5 and 6. Without prejudice to the publication of references to harmonised standards developed pursuant to Regulation (EU) No 1025/2012, the Commission shall not select or publish any reference where doing so would disproportionately favour a specific provider, group of providers, technical stack, architecture or business model, or impose unnecessary migration, re-engineering or compliance costs where less disruptive alternatives are available."Justification
As per changes to Article 35 - paragraph 5 and to ensure that open interoperability specifications, as well as common specifications are not used to distort the competition.
- Tabled by
- Piotr Müller, Diego Solier
- Group
- ECR
- Document
- IMCO amendments 125–328 to the draft opinion
- Printed header
- Article 1 – paragraph 1 – point 16 b (new) / Regulation 2023/2854 / Article 35 – paragraph 8
275 +Addition Piotr Müller +1ECR · IMCO “Before publishing any reference pursuant to paragraph 8, the Commission shall publish a notice identifying the exact version of the harmonised…” numbered 8a
In Article 35, the following paragraphs are inserted
8a.Before publishing any reference pursuant to paragraph 8, the Commission shall publish a notice identifying the exact version of the harmonised standard, common specification or open interoperability specification concerned, the data processing services covered, the expected legal effects under Article 30(3), and the rules applicable to revision, update, withdrawal, equivalence of versions, and the admission of alternative specifications or standards. The Commission shall consult data processing service providers, customers, relevant European and international standardisation bodies, and, where applicable, the organisation responsible for developing or maintaining the relevant open interoperability specification.
8b.The Commission shall publish, together with the implementing act referred to in paragraph 8, a summary of the consultation, the reasons for selecting the relevant reference, the assessment of available or possible alternatives, and the identity of any external contractors, including individuals managing the process, experts or organisations materially involved in the assessment, selection or preparation of the reference. Any substantive communication between the Commission, such contractors, experts or organisations, and the organisation responsible for developing or maintaining the relevant open interoperability specification shall be documented and made public, without prejudice to the protection of confidential business information and personal data.
Justification
This amendment establishes clear governance and transparency safeguards for the central Union standards repository without duplicating the substantive conditions in Article 35(5). It ensures that references added to the repository are version-specific, scope-limited and subject to stakeholder scrutiny. It also prevents opaque preparation of common specifications through external consultants or privileged informal channels, reducing risks of regulatory capture and ensuring equal access, market trust and better law-making.
- Tabled by
- Piotr Müller, Diego Solier
- Group
- ECR
- Document
- IMCO amendments 125–328 to the draft opinion
- Printed header
- Article 1 – paragraph 1 – point 16 c (new) / Regulation 2023/2854 / Article 35 – new paragraphs 8a and 8b