Recital 284

Commission proposal 21 January 2026 · COM(2026) 16 final

  1. (284)

    End-users are increasingly vulnerable to fraudulent activities carried out through interpersonal communications services. Several Member States have introduced national measures to combat evolving fraud schemes, such as CLI spoofing, phishing, smishing, and vishing. However, those measures remain uncoordinated and reflect primarily national perspectives, enabling fraudsters to shift their activities to jurisdictions where such practices are not effectively addressed. The ODN should enable the gathering of relevant information and best practices to enable BEREC to issue technical and legal guidelines on the measures that could effectively protect end-users against fraudulent activities in the Union. The BEREC guidelines should enable Member States adopt coordinated measures to be implemented by interpersonal communications services, with full respect of Union legislation on personal data protection. The Commission should be empowered to adopt delegated acts to supplement the effectiveness of measures that interpersonal communications services put in place to protect end-users against fraudulent activities.

Parliament amendments

ITRE draft report 20 October 2026

  1. 145 Alternative Michał KoboskoRapporteur · ITRE “End-users are increasingly vulnerable to fraudulent activities carried out through interpersonal communications services. Several Member States have…” Recital 284

    Text proposed by the Commission

    (284)End-users are increasingly vulnerable to fraudulent activities carried out through interpersonal communications services. Several Member States have introduced national measures to combat evolving fraud schemes, such as CLI spoofing, phishing, smishing, and vishing. However, those measures remain uncoordinated and reflect primarily national perspectives, enabling fraudsters to shift their activities to jurisdictions where such practices are not effectively addressed. The ODN should enable the gathering of relevant information and best practices to enable BEREC to issue technical and legal guidelines on the measures that could effectively protect end-users against fraudulent activities in the Union. The BEREC guidelines should enable Member States adopt coordinated measures to be implemented by interpersonal communications services, with full respect of Union legislation on personal data protection. The Commission should be empowered to adopt delegated acts to supplement the effectiveness of measures that interpersonal communications services put in place to protect end-users against fraudulent activities.

    Amendment

    (284)End-users are increasingly vulnerable to fraudulent activities carried out through interpersonal communications services. Several Member States have introduced national measures to combat evolving fraud schemes, such as CLI spoofing, phishing, smishing, and vishing. However, those measures remain uncoordinated and reflect primarily national perspectives, enabling fraudsters to shift their activities to jurisdictions where such practices are not effectively addressed. Providers of internet access services, providers of publicly available interpersonal communications services and transit service providers operating in a Member State should cooperate with national competent authorities to identify and implement effective measures to prevent fraudulent activities affecting end-users. The BEREC should gather relevant information, including from Europol and ENISA, and best practices to enable BEREC to issue technical and legal guidelines on the measures that could effectively protect end-users against fraudulent activities in the Union, including on the implementation of effective information sharing for the prevention, detection and mitigation of fraudulent activities. The BEREC guidelines should enable Member States adopt coordinated measures to be implemented by interpersonal communications services, with full respect of Union legislation on personal data protection. Where justified for the effectiveness of measures to prevent fraudulent activities, providers of internet access services and providers of publicly available interpersonal communications services may derogate from Articles 6 and 9 of Directive 2002/58/EC and the national laws transposing them. The Commission should be empowered to adopt delegated acts to supplement the effectiveness of measures that interpersonal communications services put in place to protect end-users against fraudulent activities

    Rapporteur
    Michał Kobosko
    Group
    Rapporteur
    Document
    ITRE draft report
    Printed header
    Recital 284

LIBE opinion 6 November 2026

  1. 12 Alternative Ana VasconcelosRapporteur · LIBE opinion “End-users are increasingly vulnerable to fraudulent activities carried out through interpersonal communications services. These activities are highly…” Recital 284

    Text proposed by the Commission

    (284)End-users are increasingly vulnerable to fraudulent activities carried out through interpersonal communications services. Several Member States have introduced national measures to combat evolving fraud schemes, such as CLI spoofing, phishing, smishing, and vishing. However, those measures remain uncoordinated and reflect primarily national perspectives, enabling fraudsters to shift their activities to jurisdictions where such practices are not effectively addressed. The ODN should enable the gathering of relevant information and best practices to enable BEREC to issue technical and legal guidelines on the measures that could effectively protect end-users against fraudulent activities in the Union. The BEREC guidelines should enable Member States adopt coordinated measures to be implemented by interpersonal communications services, with full respect of Union legislation on personal data protection. The Commission should be empowered to adopt delegated acts to supplement the effectiveness of measures that interpersonal communications services put in place to protect end-users against fraudulent activities.

    Amendment

    (284)End-users are increasingly vulnerable to fraudulent activities carried out through interpersonal communications services. These activities are highly pervasive, undermining legitimate communication channels, and are defrauding and distressing European businesses and consumers. Providers also have an interest to combat fraudulent activities. Several Member States have introduced national measures to combat evolving fraud schemes, such as CLI spoofing, phishing (impersonation fraud), smishing (SMS scams), and vishing (voice scams) and scam URLs. However, those measures remain uncoordinated and reflect primarily national perspectives, enabling fraudsters to shift their activities to jurisdictions where such practices are not effectively addressed. The ODN should enable the gathering of relevant information and best practices to enable BEREC to issue technical and legal guidelines on the measures that could effectively protect end-users against fraudulent activities in the Union. The BEREC guidelines should enable Member States to adopt coordinated measures to be implemented by interpersonal communications services, with full respect of Union legislation on privacy and protection of personal data. These guidelines should be updated when necessary in order to ensure that the deployed solutions remain effective over time.

    Rapporteur
    Ana Vasconcelos
    Group
    Rapporteur
    Document
    LIBE opinion
    Printed header
    Recital 284
Earlier LIBE texts

LIBE draft opinion 9 June 2026

  1. 6 Alternative Ana VasconcelosRapporteur · LIBE “End-users are increasingly vulnerable to fraudulent activities carried out through interpersonal communications services. These activities are highly…” Recital 284

    Text proposed by the Commission

    (284)End-users are increasingly vulnerable to fraudulent activities carried out through interpersonal communications services. Several Member States have introduced national measures to combat evolving fraud schemes, such as CLI spoofing, phishing, smishing, and vishing. However, those measures remain uncoordinated and reflect primarily national perspectives, enabling fraudsters to shift their activities to jurisdictions where such practices are not effectively addressed. The ODN should enable the gathering of relevant information and best practices to enable BEREC to issue technical and legal guidelines on the measures that could effectively protect end-users against fraudulent activities in the Union. The BEREC guidelines should enable Member States adopt coordinated measures to be implemented by interpersonal communications services, with full respect of Union legislation on personal data protection. The Commission should be empowered to adopt delegated acts to supplement the effectiveness of measures that interpersonal communications services put in place to protect end-users against fraudulent activities.

    Amendment

    (284)End-users are increasingly vulnerable to fraudulent activities carried out through interpersonal communications services. These activities are highly pervasive, undermining legitimate communication channels, and are defrauding and distressing European businesses and consumers. Several Member States have introduced national measures to combat evolving fraud schemes, such as CLI spoofing, phishing, smishing (SMS scams), vishing (voice scams) and scam URLs. However, those measures remain uncoordinated and reflect primarily national perspectives, enabling fraudsters to shift their activities to jurisdictions where such practices are not effectively addressed. The ODN should enable the gathering of relevant information and best practices to enable BEREC to issue technical and legal guidelines on the measures that could effectively protect end-users against fraudulent activities in the Union. The BEREC guidelines should enable Member States to adopt coordinated measures to be implemented by interpersonal communications services, with full respect of Union legislation on personal data protection. The Commission should be empowered to adopt delegated acts to supplement the effectiveness of measures that interpersonal communications services put in place to protect end-users against fraudulent activities.

    Rapporteur
    Ana Vasconcelos
    Group
    Rapporteur
    Document
    LIBE draft opinion
    Printed header
    Recital 284

LIBE amendments 51–310 to the draft opinion 1 July 2026

  1. 116 Alternative Sebastian TynkkynenECR · LIBE “End-users are increasingly vulnerable to fraudulent activities carried out through interpersonal communications services. Several Member States have…” Recital 284

    Text proposed by the Commission

    (284)End-users are increasingly vulnerable to fraudulent activities carried out through interpersonal communications services. Several Member States have introduced national measures to combat evolving fraud schemes, such as CLI spoofing, phishing, smishing, and vishing. However, those measures remain uncoordinated and reflect primarily national perspectives, enabling fraudsters to shift their activities to jurisdictions where such practices are not effectively addressed. The ODN should enable the gathering of relevant information and best practices to enable BEREC to issue technical and legal guidelines on the measures that could effectively protect end-users against fraudulent activities in the Union. The BEREC guidelines should enable Member States to adopt coordinated measures to be implemented by interpersonal communications services, with full respect of Union legislation on personal data protection. The Commission should be empowered to adopt delegated acts to supplement the effectiveness of measures that interpersonal communications services put in place to protect end-users against fraudulent activities.

    Amendment

    (284)End-users are increasingly vulnerable to fraudulent activities carried out through interpersonal communications services. Several Member States have introduced national measures to combat evolving fraud schemes, such as CLI spoofing, phishing, smishing, and vishing. However, those measures remain uncoordinated and reflect primarily national perspectives, enabling fraudsters to shift their activities to jurisdictions where such practices are not effectively addressed. The ODN should enable the gathering of relevant information and best practices to enable BEREC to issue technical and legal guidelines on the measures that could effectively protect end-users against fraudulent activities in the Union. The BEREC guidelines should enable Member States to adopt coordinated measures to be implemented by interpersonal communications services, with full respect of Union legislation on personal data protection and the need to maintain end-to-end encryption.

    Tabled by
    Sebastian Tynkkynen
    Group
    ECR
    Document
    LIBE amendments 51–310 to the draft opinion
    Printed header
    Recital 284
  2. 117 Alternative François-Xavier BellamyEPP · LIBE “End-users are increasingly vulnerable to fraudulent activities carried out through interpersonal communications services. Several Member States have…” Recital 284

    Text proposed by the Commission

    (284)End-users are increasingly vulnerable to fraudulent activities carried out through interpersonal communications services. Several Member States have introduced national measures to combat evolving fraud schemes, such as CLI spoofing, phishing, smishing, and vishing. However, those measures remain uncoordinated and reflect primarily national perspectives, enabling fraudsters to shift their activities to jurisdictions where such practices are not effectively addressed. The ODN should enable the gathering of relevant information and best practices to enable BEREC to issue technical and legal guidelines on the measures that could effectively protect end-users against fraudulent activities in the Union. The BEREC guidelines should enable Member States adopt coordinated measures to be implemented by interpersonal communications services, with full respect of Union legislation on personal data protection. The Commission should be empowered to adopt delegated acts to supplement the effectiveness of measures that interpersonal communications services put in place to protect end-users against fraudulent activities.

    Amendment

    (284)End-users are increasingly vulnerable to fraudulent activities carried out through interpersonal communications services. Several Member States have introduced national measures to combat evolving fraud schemes, such as CLI spoofing, phishing, smishing, and vishing. However, providers of publicly available interpersonal communications services remain challenged due to the application of Directive 2002/58/EC, which prevents providers to put in place technical measures due to different interpretations across Member States. Providers have a legitimate interest to combat fraudulent practices and should be able to deploy technical measures in compliance with Regulation (EU) 2016/679. In order to ensure that providers can act with agility, they should be entrusted to decide which technical solutions should be deployed across their businesses in the EU. BEREC should on a regular basis collect information on best practices in order to ensure that deployed solutions remain effective over time.

    Tabled by
    François-Xavier Bellamy
    Group
    EPP
    Document
    LIBE amendments 51–310 to the draft opinion
    Printed header
    Recital 284
  3. 118 Alternative Evin IncirS&D · LIBE “End-users are increasingly vulnerable to fraudulent activities carried out through interpersonal communications services. Several Member States have…” Recital 284

    Text proposed by the Commission

    (284)End-users are increasingly vulnerable to fraudulent activities carried out through interpersonal communications services. Several Member States have introduced national measures to combat evolving fraud schemes, such as CLI spoofing, phishing, smishing, and vishing. However, those measures remain uncoordinated and reflect primarily national perspectives, enabling fraudsters to shift their activities to jurisdictions where such practices are not effectively addressed. The ODN should enable the gathering of relevant information and best practices to enable BEREC to issue technical and legal guidelines on the measures that could effectively protect end-users against fraudulent activities in the Union. The BEREC guidelines should enable Member States adopt coordinated measures to be implemented by interpersonal communications services, with full respect of Union legislation on personal data protection. The Commission should be empowered to adopt delegated acts to supplement the effectiveness of measures that interpersonal communications services put in place to protect end-users against fraudulent activities.

    Amendment

    (284)End-users are increasingly vulnerable to fraudulent activities carried out through interpersonal communications services. Several Member States have introduced national measures to combat evolving fraud schemes, such as CLI spoofing, phishing, smishing, and vishing. However, those measures remain uncoordinated and reflect primarily national perspectives, enabling fraudsters to shift their activities to jurisdictions where such practices are not effectively addressed. The ODN should enable the gathering of relevant information and best practices to enable BEREC to issue technical and legal guidelines on the measures that could effectively protect end-users against fraudulent activities in the Union. The BEREC guidelines should enable Member States adopt coordinated measures to be implemented by interpersonal communications services, with full respect of Union legislation on privacy and protection of personal data. The Commission should be empowered to adopt delegated acts to supplement the effectiveness of measures that interpersonal communications services put in place to protect end-users against fraudulent activities.

    Tabled by
    Evin Incir
    Group
    S&D
    Document
    LIBE amendments 51–310 to the draft opinion
    Printed header
    Recital 284
  4. 119 Addition Damien CarêmeThe Left · LIBE “The confidentiality of electronic communications and of related metadata is a fundamental right enshrined in Article 7 of the Charter of Fundamental…” Recital 284 a (new)

    Text proposed by the Commission

    Nothing printed in this column.

    Amendment

    (284a)The confidentiality of electronic communications and of related metadata is a fundamental right enshrined in Article 7 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights, and the protection of personal data is a fundamental right enshrined in Article 8 of the Charter. The integration into this Regulation of provisions formerly contained in Directive 2002/58/EC should not, under any interpretation, lower the level of protection enjoyed by end-users. Any interference with the content of communications or related metadata, whether by human intervention or automated processing, is prohibited unless expressly permitted by Union law.

    Tabled by
    Damien Carême
    Group
    The Left
    Document
    LIBE amendments 51–310 to the draft opinion
    Printed header
    Recital 284 a (new)
  5. 120 Addition Markéta GregorováGreens/EFA · LIBE “The confidentiality of electronic communications and of the related metadata is a fundamental right under Article 7, and the protection of personal…” Recital 284 a (new)

    Text proposed by the Commission

    Nothing printed in this column.

    Amendment

    (284a)The confidentiality of electronic communications and of the related metadata is a fundamental right under Article 7, and the protection of personal data is a fundamental right under Article 8 of the Charter of fundamental rights. The integration into this Regulation of provisions formerly contained in Directive 2002/58/EC shall not, under any reading, lower the level of protection enjoyed by end-users. Any interference with communications content or metadata, whether by human intervention or automated processing, is prohibited unless expressly permitted by Union law.

    Tabled by
    Markéta Gregorová
    Group
    Greens/EFA
    Document
    LIBE amendments 51–310 to the draft opinion
    Printed header
    Recital 284 a (new)