LIBE opinion Amendment 16

Recital 307

Document
LIBE opinion
Rapporteur
Ana Vasconcelos
  1. 16 Alternative Ana VasconcelosRapporteur · LIBE opinion “Publicly available directories consist of any directory or service containing information of end-users, such as phone numbers (including mobile phone…” Recital 307

    Text proposed by the Commission

    (307)Publicly available directories consist of any directory or service containing information of end-users, such as phone numbers (including mobile phone numbers), email address, contact details and includes inquiry services. The main function of directory services is to enable to identify such persons. The increasing availability and use of digital alternatives like online search engines, social media and online directories that offer an up-to-date way to find contact information do not justify maintaining the obligation on number-based interpersonal communications services providers. In addition, many directory enquiry services are now available as apps or online, allowing users to search for information digitally. Furthermore, it is appropriate for ensuring a high level of protection of the right to privacy and to protection of the personal data that end-users who are natural persons are asked for consent before their personal data are included in a directory. Different from natural persons, legitimate interests of legal entities related to their data being included in a directory should be also protected. The application of Directive 2002/58/EC showed divergent practices across Member States as regards the exercise of the choice of end-users that are natural persons for inclusion of their personal data in a directory. Sometimes, Member States provide that end-users have the right to object the inclusion of their personal data in their national laws or the withdrawal of consent of a natural person is not shared with third parties processing personal data from the directories, which may not only lower the level of protection throughout the Union, but also expose end-users to fraudulent practices by malicious actors. Requesting consent, including for sharing contact details in an electronic or paper form irrespective of the provider should be in accordance with Regulation (EU) 2016/679.

    Amendment

    (307)Publicly available directories consist of any directory or service containing information of end-users, such as phone numbers (including mobile phone numbers), email address, contact details and includes inquiry services. The main function of directory services is to enable to identify such persons. In addition, many directory enquiry services are now available as apps or online, allowing users to search for information digitally. Furthermore, it is appropriate for ensuring a high level of protection of the right to privacy and to protection of the personal data that end-users who are natural persons are asked for consent before their personal data are included in a directory. Different from natural persons, legitimate interests of legal entities related to their data being included in a directory should be also protected. The application of Directive 2002/58/EC showed divergent practices across Member States as regards the exercise of the choice of end-users that are natural persons for inclusion of their personal data in a directory. Sometimes, Member States provide that end-users have the right to object the inclusion of their personal data in their national laws or the withdrawal of consent of a natural person is not shared with third parties processing personal data from the directories, which may not only lower the level of protection throughout the Union, but also expose end-users to fraudulent practices by malicious actors. Requesting consent for sharing contact details in an electronic form irrespective of the provider should always be required.

    Rapporteur
    Ana Vasconcelos
    Group
    Rapporteur
    Document
    LIBE opinion
    Printed header
    Recital 307

Cite

Amendment 16 (opinion by Ana Vasconcelos), European Parliament, Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs, opinion on COM(2026) 16 (LIBE-AD-789917, PE789.917v02-00, 6 November 2026), pp. 16–17

https://research.eutechreg.com/trackers/digital-networks-act/amendments/libe-opinion-16/